With Canada’s Economy in Transition, the Neutral Rate is Key in 2019

We are skeptical Canada can shift its growth model, and our investment outlook for Canada is cautious as a result.

Explaining the current state of the Canadian economy is simple. Economic growth in Canada has been a one-trick pony since the financial crisis in 2008: Consumer debt has fueled expansion, with consumption and residential housing investment accounting for approximately 93% of real GDP growth since the crisis.

Forecasting economic growth and structuring bond portfolios for 2019 are much more difficult, however, because an elevated share of growth built on consumer debt and housing is ultimately unsustainable. Will the Bank of Canada (BoC) be successful in its plan to rotate the growth model to business investment and exports? We are skeptical – and our investment outlook for Canada this year is cautious as a result.

Reasons to be skeptical

The BoC is forecasting (perhaps hoping) that the transition to higher business investment and exports will be relatively smooth. We are less optimistic for four reasons:

  • Housing markets look vulnerable. Our main concerns are the overheating markets in Toronto and Vancouver, which are facing new local regulations designed to cool them. Also, new federally mandated rules are intended to tighten mortgage credit. And finally, policy rates are higher, which has lifted some mortgage rates. The mix of these three developments already slowed Canadian housing markets in 2018, and although the path of house prices in 2019 is unclear, we think the risk is weighted to the downside (see Figure 1).

    Figure 1 is a line graph measuring the year-over-year percentage change in Canadian housing prices from 2006 to 2018, marked in eight month increments on the X-axis. Over time, Vancouver shows the most volatile fluctuations. All three rates have been falling since 2016 or 2017, reaching around zero in late 2018. Vancouver’s rate peaked at greater than 30% in 2016, as did Toronto’s in 2017. The national rate is much more moderate over time, peaking at around 20% in 2017. class=
  • The risks tilt toward a more notable deceleration in consumption. With housing markets cooling, we expect less consumption based on a reverse wealth effect (see Figure 2). In addition, the most indebted consumers will likely have to tighten their belts due to higher rates, and overall wage growth has been falling over the past six months or so. The BoC recognized this in early January when it revised down its forecast for consumption growth in 2019. Again, we see more downside than upside risk to this forecast.

    Figure 3 is a line graph showing household debt to disposable income from 1990 to 2018. The ratio was around 90% in 1990, and steadily rises over time, reaching 175 by 2015, then almost 180 in 2016, where it has hovered since.

3) Disruptions and low business investment in the oil sector should be headwinds to real growth. In January, the BoC estimated that lower oil prices would detract 0.5% from real GDP growth (on the high end of our 0.25%—0.5% estimate).  Lackluster business investment, meanwhile, has been a global issue since the end of the financial crisis. While there are positive signals in the BoC’s Business Outlook Survey, we think that BoC Governor Stephen Poloz’s term “serial disappointments” will continue to apply to this sector in 2019.

4) The BoC’s 2019 real GDP estimate relies upon a robust export forecast, which we think may be too optimistic. While the new NAFTA (aka USMCA) has been agreed by political leaders, it faces challenges passing the U.S. Congress, with the potential for more drama in the U.S. before it becomes law. Even more important are the trade talks between the U.S. and China, which have broad implications for global trade, asset prices and business/consumer confidence. We do not see “clear sailing” on the trade front for Canada in 2019.

Despite our skepticism, two upside risks to growth could change the picture. First, strong employment growth is a key tailwind. The unemployment rate of 5.6% is a multi-decade low, and monthly employment growth has been robust, averaging over 20,000 new jobs over the past three years. If this were to continue or accelerate, it would represent a meaningful upside risk to the economy. That said, Canada has been accepting more immigrants (with a goal of 340,000 by 2020, up from around 273,000 in 2017), which may be a reason wage growth has not accelerated; in fact, average hourly wage growth for permanent workers has dropped from almost 4% in May 2018 to 1.5% in December.

Second, we should expect fiscal stimulus in the election-year federal budget. The incumbent government is likely to hand out goodies before voters go to the polls this fall. Part of this stimulus may be offset by consolidation in Ontario, but our overall view is that we should see a net modest fiscal stimulus this year.

What will the Bank of Canada do?

For bond investors, this is the key question. To predict the answer, we have to decide whether the BoC believes it is propping up a weak economy, slowing a strong economy, or simply trying to keep economic growth and inflation where they are.

Crucial to this determination is an interest rate that we cannot observe: the “neutral rate,” which is the theoretical interest rate that will keep the economy steady, with inflation at the BoC’s target of 2% and full employment (or the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment, NAIRU).

In April’s Monetary Policy Report (MPR), the BoC will update its estimate of the neutral rate, currently 3% +/- 0.5% (or 2.5%−3.5%). In our view, this estimate is too high. We find it compelling that inflation expectations and term premiums have fallen in recent years. Canada’s demographics and immigration are strong, but the apparent slowdown in productivity growth is a significant offset. More important, Canada’s massive stock of debt (particularly consumer debt) makes it highly unlikely to us that a sustainable neutral rate could be as high as 3.5%. We believe the economy would buckle under the strain of an overnight rate this high.

Our research leads us to a neutral rate estimate of 2%−3%, with a bias to the lower end of the range.

While this may seem academic, it is very important in the real world of investing. By hiking 0.25% five times since July 2017, the BoC may have taken out most (if not all) of its monetary stimulus, in our view, and if so, future rate hikes will not be taking the foot off the gas but rather applying the brakes to the Canadian economy. The effects of interest rate changes tend not to be fully observed until 12−18 months afterward, so in 2019, we should be able to see if the rate changes in 2017−2018 were appropriate.    

We will pay very close attention in April to see if the BoC changes its neutral rate estimate and the rationale behind the decision. Often the devil is in the details when it comes to bond investing.

Investment implications

We see headwinds to the economy and the confining effects of a lower neutral interest rate limiting further rate increases by the BoC. In this context, we think interest rates should be range-bound, with a recession still unlikely over the next year. Low oil prices and the Federal Reserve’s more dovish stance of late make us cautious on the Canadian dollar, as both should limit any hawkish rhetoric from the BoC.

Despite our expectation for modest inflation this year, the breakeven inflation rate has dropped to 1.40%, making real return bonds relatively attractive as a hedge against upside surprises in inflation. Within the credit markets, our more cautious view on the fundamentals of the Canadian economy and high leverage in the system (both consumer and corporate) lead us to a bias for higher-quality investments and for avoiding highly cyclical sectors and those that are heavily levered to the consumer. 

Since October, front-end bond yields have dropped 50 basis points, and we no longer see value in the front end of the yield curve. In this range-bound market, we are focused instead on opportunities at higher yields.

The Author

Michael Kim

Portfolio Manager, U.S. Financial Institutions and Canada

Vinayak Seshasayee

Portfolio Manager, Generalist



PIMCO Japan Ltd
Toranomon Towers Office 18F
4-1-28, Toranomon, Minato-ku
Tokyo, Japan 105-0001

Financial Instruments Business Registration Number: Director of Kanto Local Finance Bureau (Financial Instruments Firm) No.382. Member of Japan Investment Advisers Association and The Investment Trusts Association, Japan.

Investment management products and services offered by PIMCO Japan Ltd are offered only to persons within its respective jurisdiction, and are not available to persons where provision of such products or services is unauthorized.

Past performance is not a guarantee or a reliable indicator of future results. PIMCO as a general matter provides services to qualified institutions, financial intermediaries and institutional investors. Individual investors should contact their own financial professional to determine the most appropriate investment options for their financial situation. This material contains the opinions of the manager and such opinions are subject to change without notice. This material has been distributed for informational purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed.

Past performance is not a guarantee or a reliable indicator of future results. All investments contain risk and may lose value. Investing in the bond market is subject to risks, including market, interest rate, issuer, credit, inflation risk, and liquidity risk. The value of most bonds and bond strategies are impacted by changes in interest rates. Bonds and bond strategies with longer durations tend to be more sensitive and volatile than those with shorter durations; bond prices generally fall as interest rates rise, and the current low interest rate environment increases this risk. Current reductions in bond counterparty capacity may contribute to decreased market liquidity and increased price volatility. Bond investments may be worth more or less than the original cost when redeemed. Investing in foreign-denominated and/or -domiciled securities may involve heightened risk due to currency fluctuations, and economic and political risks, which may be enhanced in emerging markets. High yield, lower-rated securities involve greater risk than higher-rated securities; portfolios that invest in them may be subject to greater levels of credit and liquidity risk than portfolios that do not. Inflation-linked bonds (ILBs) issued by a government are fixed income securities whose principal value is periodically adjusted according to the rate of inflation; ILBs decline in value when real interest rates rise. Derivatives may involve certain costs and risks, such as liquidity, interest rate, market, credit, management and the risk that a position could not be closed when most advantageous. Investing in derivatives could lose more than the amount invested.

Statements concerning financial market trends or portfolio strategies are based on current market conditions, which will fluctuate. There is no guarantee that these investment strategies will work under all market conditions or are suitable for all investors and each investor should evaluate their ability to invest for the long term, especially during periods of downturn in the market. Outlook and strategies are subject to change without notice. Investors should consult their investment professional prior to making an investment decision.

This material contains the opinions of the manager and such opinions are subject to change without notice. This material has been distributed for informational purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed. No part of this material may be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without express written permission. PIMCO is a trademark of Allianz Asset Management of America L.P. in the United States and throughout the world. ©2019, PIMCO.